Amendment 3 – What Did We Vote For? Do You Really Know? Part 1: 11-21-26 Podcast
Real Estate Matters has been Palm Coast and Flagler County, Florida’s real estate voice for more than 12 years.
In this two-part series, we ask Flagler County Property Appraiser Jay Gardner about the passage of Amendment 3. Who are the likely winners and losers?
You might be surprised to learn that you may not be a winner once the revenue replacement and level-of-service issues are settled. The projected revenue loss greatly exceeds reasonable expectations of spending reductions. Many long-term residents are vastly overestimating their savings while ignoring the inevitable (as yet unidentified) revenue replacement schemes.
Will the five-year waiting period be challenged? Probably. Will it be overturned? Probably.
Watch the Podcast and read the Show Notes below for more details.
October Flagler County Price-Layered Home Sales Map
Be sure to check out the continually updated interactive Flagler County Map of Developments and Subdivisions.
Raw Show Notes
Show Notes for 11-21-2026 and 11-28-2026
Recorded 11-19-2026
Welcome to the tranquil side of Florida. This is Real Estate Matters, the voice of real estate in Flagler County and Palm Coast for more than 12 years.
I’m Toby Tobin, publisher of the real estate news website GoToby.com, and a Florida-licensed Realtor with Grand Living Realty. Co-host Annamaria Long is with me in the studio today.
Thanks to Our Sponsors:
- Flagler County Home Builders Association
- Hammock Community Church
Guest: Flagler County Property Appraiser, Jay Gardner
Month-to-date data:
Pretty much where we were at this time last November, except the median price is down $30,000 from a year ago. Price per SF is down about $10/SF.
Total listings are down slightly, but the GINNdex, the % of pending listings that are new construction, and the listing price of pending listings are all close to last year’s levels.
But, again, the median price is down measurably. Why?
Main Topic: What will the market drivers be over the next year or two? Today and next week, we will be discussing the following topics and their affect on the real estate market.
Amendment 3
Westward Expansion.
New members on the County Commission, Flagler Beach City Council, and Palm Coast City Council.
Anti-growthism and its associated legal costs.
Lack of a coherent plan to recruit commercial development.
Area demographics. Age, education, spending habits.
Palm Coast acquisition of 17 entitled parcels in Town Center.
Politics, not only at the local level, but at the state and national levels as well.
Questions to ask:
What will Amendment 3 affect:
- Existing homesteaded residents – potential winners
- Existing non-homesteaded residents buying a home – gain changes in 2027 but no portability
- New homebuyers from out of state – delayed benefit
- Commercial property owners – mixed results
- Renters (residential and commercial) – lose
- Local budgets
What are the most likely sources of replacement revenue? Local use fees, increased millage rate, optional sales tax, usage fees, impact fees, special taxing districts.
What is the legal difference between a tax and a fee?
What is the real difference? Both are decreed by the government, and both are involuntary.
Five years from now, will we regret or applaud Amendment 3?
The Westward Expansion is baked into the state’s regional vision. Has this vision been stopped or simply delayed?
It’s the feeling of many, including myself, that local governments have become dysfunctional and overly responsive to social media and a vocal minority. Is that likely to change with newly elected officials?
Compared to the two previous developers of Town Center, how well do you expect the Palm Coast City Council to perform in marketing their newly acquired parcels? Are they likely to hold themselves to the same rigid standards that they imposed on the past development project proposals that spawned the lawsuit? Probably not. They will bend under increasing pressure to sell off non-tax-paying land.
Do our demographics doom us to perpetually be a retirement community of suburban sprawl misers that offers nothing to attract potential job creating commercial growth?
Explain how new commercial development can increase traffic trip counts in the nearby area but reduce trip lengths overall.
Wrap-up:
Video podcasts of Real Estate Matters are available on GoToby.com. Click on Podcasts on the top navigation bar. Show notes are included so you can see what we didn’t get to on the show.
If you are thinking about buying or selling property in Flagler County, do what some of your neighbors are doing. Call Toby first. Based on your goals, I’ll connect you with an appropriately qualified Realtor or builder and serve as your consultant throughout the transaction, at no additional cost to you. Call me at 386-931-7124 or email me at Toby@GoToby.com.

Leave a Reply
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!